CallingPost vs. DialMyCalls: Which Mass Messaging Platform Is Right for Your Organization?

The short answer: CallingPost is the better choice for churches, schools, nonprofits, and community organizations that need reliable group messaging, transparent pricing, and real human support. Here's the full breakdown.

If you've been comparing CallingPost and Dial My Calls, you've already done the hard part: narrowing down to two solid options. Both send voice calls, texts, and emails to large groups. Both are US-based. Both have been around for years.

But the details matter — especially when you're the person responsible for getting an urgent message out on a Sunday morning or a snow day. This guide breaks down every dimension that matters: pricing, features, reliability, support, and real customer reviews. No fluff, no vague claims.

---

The Companies Behind the Platform

CallingPost has been doing this since 1995 — nearly a decade before DialMyCalls existed. It's independently owned, headquartered in Augusta, Georgia, with an in-house US-based support team that has served 20,000+ organizations and delivered over 100 million messages at a 99.9% success rate. The people who built it are the same people who answer when you call.

DialMyCalls launched in 2006 under OnTimeTelecom, Inc. out of Jupiter, Florida. It's also independent and US-based, and has grown to 40,000+ customers with over a billion messages sent. Solid credentials — but it's a newer company, and the customer experience reflects that.

Pricing: Looks Similar, Feels Different

At first glance, pricing is almost identical. CallingPost starts at $6.30/month, DialMyCalls at around $6.74/month. But there's a catch with DialMyCalls that trips up a lot of new customers.

Two-way texting costs extra. On DialMyCalls' Standard and Pay-as-You-Go plans, it's an additional $14.99/month. With CallingPost's Premium Plan, it's included — no add-on, no surprise charge.

The credit system at DialMyCalls is also worth scrutinizing. One credit covers a 30-second call per contact — so a 90-second message costs three credits per person. Multiple G2 and Capterra reviewers discovered mid-campaign that their costs were two or three times what they'd budgeted. CallingPost's pricing has no such gotchas.

Plan	CallingPost	Dial My Calls
Free Trial	✅ Up to 10 contacts, no credit card	✅ 25 messages, no credit card
Entry-Level Monthly	$6.30/month	~$6.74/month
Two-Way Texting	✅ Included (Premium)	⚠️ +$14.99/month (Standard)
Pay-as-You-Go	✅ Available	✅ Available
No Contracts	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Nonprofit Discount	⚠️ Not listed (low base price)	✅ 10% discount

Bottom line on pricing: Both platforms are affordable. But CallingPost is more predictable — and for budget-conscious nonprofits and community organizations, predictable is better.

Features: Where Each Platform Wins

Feature	CallingPost	Dial My Calls
Voice Broadcasting	✅	✅
SMS / Text Messaging	✅	✅
Email Broadcasts	✅	✅
Two-Way Texting	✅ Included	⚠️ +$14.99/mo
Text Polling	✅	✅
Text-to-Speech	✅	✅
Shortcode SMS	❌	✅
Landline Text-Enabling	❌	✅ Free
Toll-Free Dial-In (no internet)	❌	✅
Zapier / Salesforce / HubSpot	❌	✅
Dedicated Mobile App	❌	✅ iOS + Android
Scheduled / 24/7 Messaging	✅	✅
RSVP Tracking	❌	✅

To be fair: DialMyCalls wins on feature count. Shortcode SMS, third-party integrations, a native mobile app, landline texting, and a toll-free dial-in line for sending alerts without internet — these are real advantages for organizations with technical workflows or specific infrastructure needs.

But here's the honest question: does your church, school, or community group actually need Salesforce integration? For the vast majority of CallingPost's customers, the answer is no. What they need is fast, reliable messaging with two-way texting included — and that's exactly what CallingPost delivers, without the learning curve or the add-on fees.

Reliability: The Number That Matters Most

CallingPost publishes a 99.9% message success rate. DialMyCalls does not publish an equivalent figure — and non-incentivized user reviews on Capterra note occasional delivery inconsistencies: messages cut off mid-recording, voicemails not left, and spotty reliability during actual broadcasts.

When you're sending a school closure or a weather emergency, a message that doesn't land isn't just an inconvenience. It's a failure. CallingPost's track record here isn't marketing copy — it's 30 years of infrastructure built specifically for this.

Reliability Factor	CallingPost	Dial My Calls
Published Success Rate	✅ 99.9%	❌ Not published
US-Owned Data Centers	✅ Yes	✅ Yes (multiple)
Delivery Reports	✅ Live answer vs. voicemail breakdown	✅ Per-contact reports
Consistent Delivery (user reviews)	✅ Highly consistent	⚠️ Some reported inconsistencies
Emergency No-Internet Fallback	❌	✅ Toll-free dial-in

Support: The Biggest Difference Nobody Talks About

	CallingPost	Dial My Calls
US-Based Support Team	✅ In-house, dedicated	✅ 7 days/week
Proactive Account Monitoring	✅ They call you if something's wrong	❌
One-on-One Setup Calls	✅	❌
Live Training Webinars	✅	❌
BBB Accreditation	✅ Active, in good standing	❌ Not accredited
Agent Satisfaction Rating	✅ 95%+	⚠️ Not published

Both platforms offer phone and chat support. But CallingPost's team is a different animal entirely. Customers don't just rate the support highly — they name specific reps in their reviews. They describe situations where CallingPost noticed a delivery issue and called them to fix it before they ever knew there was a problem.

DialMyCalls' support starts strong for most users, but organic reviews tell a more complicated story over time. One long-term customer wrote: "I chose for pricing and chat availability and reviews. Now the price has increased, the service has gone down, and the reliability is spotty at best." That's the kind of review that only appears when a customer volunteers it.

Customer Ratings

CallingPost: 4.9 / 5 — Google, 500+ reviews

Dial My Calls: 4.72 / 5 — Aggregate, 1,200+ reviews

DialMyCalls has more total reviews. CallingPost has a higher score — and a customer base that comes back year after year. Many CallingPost reviewers have been with the platform for a decade or more. That kind of retention doesn't happen by accident.

What CallingPost customers say:

• Extremely responsive support — customers name specific reps by name

• "We've used CallingPost for over 10 years and it never lets us down"

• Reliable, on-time delivery with no surprises

• Proactive issue resolution before the customer even notices

• Easy enough for non-technical administrators to use from day one

What Dial My Calls customers say:

• Fast to set up for basic broadcasts

• Zapier automations praised by technically inclined users

• Text-to-speech feature is a highlight

• Credit system frequently described as confusing and costlier than expected

• Mobile app contact management cited as clunky for large lists

• Delivery inconsistencies noted in non-incentivized reviews

Who Should Choose What

Choose Dial My Calls if you need deep third-party integrations (Zapier, Salesforce, HubSpot), a native mobile app, shortcode SMS, or a toll-free dial-in line for emergencies without internet. It's a capable platform for technically sophisticated teams with complex automation needs.

Choose CallingPost if you're a church, school, nonprofit, sports league, small business, utility, or community organization that needs group messaging to just work — reliably, affordably, and with a support team that treats you like a person, not a ticket. No contracts. No hidden fees. No confusing credit math. Two-way texting included.

Full Head-to-Head Summary

Category	CallingPost	Dial My Calls
Founded	1995	2006
Headquarters	Augusta, Georgia (US)	Jupiter, Florida (US)
Organizations Served	20,000+	40,000+
Messages Delivered	100 million+	1 billion+
Published Success Rate	✅ 99.9%	❌ Not published
Starting Monthly Price	$6.30/month	~$6.74/month
Two-Way Texting Included	✅ Premium Plan	⚠️ +$14.99/mo (Standard)
Third-Party Integrations	❌ CSV only	✅ Zapier, HubSpot, Salesforce +
Dedicated Mobile App	❌ Mobile browser	✅ iOS + Android
Toll-Free Dial-In Fallback	❌	✅ Yes
Proactive Support Monitoring	✅ Yes	❌ Not offered
Live Training Webinars	✅ Yes	❌
BBB Accreditation	✅ Active	❌ Not accredited
Customer Rating	✅ 4.9 / 5 (500+ reviews)	4.72 / 5 (1,200+ reviews)

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CallingPost better than Dial My Calls?

For most community organizations — churches, schools, nonprofits, and small businesses — yes. CallingPost offers more predictable pricing (two-way texting is included rather than a $14.99/month add-on), a 99.9% published delivery success rate, and a support team that proactively monitors your account. DialMyCalls edges ahead on third-party integrations and mobile app access, making it a better fit for technically sophisticated teams.

Is CallingPost cheaper than Dial My Calls?

Starting prices are nearly identical — $6.30/month for CallingPost vs. ~$6.74/month for DialMyCalls. However, DialMyCalls charges an additional $14.99/month for two-way texting on Standard and Pay-as-You-Go plans. CallingPost includes it in the Premium Plan. For organizations that use two-way messaging, CallingPost is meaningfully more cost-effective.

Does Dial My Calls include two-way texting?

Not on all plans. Two-way texting costs an additional $14.99/month on DialMyCalls' Standard Monthly and Pay-as-You-Go plans. It is bundled with the higher-tier Premium Monthly Plan. CallingPost includes two-way texting in its Premium Plan at no extra charge.

Which is better for churches — CallingPost or Dial My Calls?

CallingPost is purpose-built for community organizations like churches and has served that segment since 1995. Many church administrators cite 10+ years of continuous use, with strong praise for the personal, US-based support team. DialMyCalls also has a large church user base and offers a 10% nonprofit/church discount. For simplicity, reliability, and support quality, most church administrators will find CallingPost the better long-term fit.

Does Dial My Calls have a mobile app?

Yes. DialMyCalls has dedicated iOS and Android apps for sending broadcasts and managing contacts. CallingPost is accessible via mobile browser but does not currently offer a standalone app — a genuine advantage for DialMyCalls if you frequently send messages from your phone.

Can Dial My Calls integrate with Zapier or Salesforce?

Yes. DialMyCalls integrates with Zapier, Salesforce, HubSpot, MailChimp, Eventbrite, and Google Calendar. CallingPost does not currently offer these integrations. If automation pipelines are central to your workflow, DialMyCalls is the stronger choice.

What is CallingPost's message delivery success rate?

CallingPost publishes a 99.9% message success rate. DialMyCalls does not publish a comparable figure, and some non-incentivized user reviews note occasional delivery inconsistencies including messages being cut off or voicemails failing to deliver during broadcasts.

Does CallingPost require a contract?

No. CallingPost has no contracts — you can cancel anytime. Monthly and annual billing options are available, and a genuine free trial with no credit card is offered upfront.

How long has CallingPost been in business?

CallingPost was founded in 1995, making it one of the oldest mass notification services in the United States. DialMyCalls was founded in 2006.

The Bottom Line

DialMyCalls is a good product. But CallingPost is built for your organization — the kind where one person manages everything, where a missed alert has real consequences, and where you want to call a real human and have them know your name.

Thirty years of that focus shows in the ratings, the retention, and the 99.9% delivery rate.

No credit card. No contract. No sales pressure. Start your free CallingPost trial →

Call or text our US-based team anytime: (877) 665-5646 · Text: (706) 510-3019